Do you get to kick the shit out of each other?
I'll give it a 9.5 too based on the ending. I think OVERALL I enjoyed the ending, I just have like a lot of gripes. Other than a massive plot hole/the KID, the ending was pretty cool. It needed a Dragon Age Origins style slideshow for closure, but it wasn't as bad as Jay makes it out to be. Is it a letdown? Sure. Does it ruin the series? Well yeah, the consequences of it do.
But honestly, aside from some technical bugs and the stupid mini map, I loved this game to death. It did a lot of things right and one thing wrong.
I give oobs the seal of approval. What ending did you choose?